The crab and the stopper

The octopus feels the glass with its suckers. In the lab, octopuses worked out how to pull out the stopper and grab the crab. They made fewer mistakes as they tried again. Think of a box you’ve had trouble opening. What might you do differently the second time?

Illustrated reconstruction of the jar task. A common octopus explores the container holding the crab.
Illustrated reconstruction of the jar task. A common octopus explores the container holding the crab. © dive.explo360.fr — All rights reserved. Reproduction requires permission.

Watching another octopus

An octopus can watch another one make a choice. When it gets a turn on its own, researchers can see if watching changed what it chooses.

A shelter to carry

A veined octopus can carry two coconut shell halves across the sand. The shells make it harder to move. Once the octopus stops, it can fit them together and hide inside.

A veined octopus shelters between two coconut shell halves.
A veined octopus shelters between two coconut shell halves. © dive.explo360.fr — All rights reserved. Reproduction requires permission.
A bluestreak cleaner wrasse (Labroides dimidiatus) faces a mirror.
A bluestreak cleaner wrasse (Labroides dimidiatus) faces a mirror. © dive.explo360.fr — All rights reserved. Reproduction requires permission.

A fish and its reflection

Researchers put a coloured mark where a cleaner wrasse could only see it in a mirror. Some fish rubbed the marked spot against a surface. They acted differently when they couldn’t see the mark in the mirror.

Which customer comes first?

A cleaner wrasse eats parasites, tiny animals that live on other fish. Some of the fish it cleans can swim away. In a tank, cleaner wrasses learnt to eat first from the plate that could be taken away. Then they could still eat from the other one.

A cleaner wrasse approaches a client fish on the reef.
A cleaner wrasse approaches a client fish on the reef. © dive.explo360.fr — All rights reserved. Reproduction requires permission.
A grouper and a giant moray meet near a crevice.
A grouper and a giant moray meet near a crevice. © dive.explo360.fr — All rights reserved. Reproduction requires permission.

Two hunters at a crack

In the Red Sea, a grouper can shake its head beside a moray eel, which sometimes comes out of hiding. Follow the two hunters. The grouper can chase fish in open water. The moray can enter a crack where a small fish has hidden.

A grouper turns head down above a prey fish’s hiding place.
A grouper turns head down above a prey fish’s hiding place. © dive.explo360.fr — All rights reserved. Reproduction requires permission.

Does it remember what worked?

After a break, can the animal solve the same problem again? Researchers watch to see if it uses the same trick or has to work it out again.

Returning to the jar

An octopus might open a jar once by chance. When researchers watch it try again, they can see whether it uses the same move to get the stopper out.

Three examples for comparing learning, choice and coordination.
An octopus opens a jar, a wrasse chooses a client, and two fish hunt together. © dive.explo360.fr — All rights reserved. Reproduction requires permission.

Interactive quiz

Test what you know

Pick one answer for each question.

Conclusion

One octopus gets better at opening a jar. Another carries shells it can turn into a hiding place. A grouper can bring a moray along on a hunt. If you’re watching an animal, see what happens just before it makes a move and what changes afterwards.

Sources

Studies behind the examples in this article.